INDEPENDENT EXPLAINERS & GENERAL KNOWLEDGEKnow more. Think clearly.
Auto & Tech · News report

Reddit calls Australia's teen social media ban 'ill-thought-out' in High Court challenge

Reddit has argued in Australia's High Court that the country's ban on social media accounts for under-16s is "ill-thought-out" and breaches an implied freedom of political communication.

By · Published · Updated · 3 min read

The short answer

Reddit has told Australia's High Court that the country's world-first ban on social media accounts for under-16s is "ill-thought-out" and a "profound restriction on political debate". Reddit and a libertarian advocacy group argue the law breaches an implied freedom of political communication in the constitution; the government says it will defend the law.

What the ban does

Australia's world-first ban on social media for children under 16 requires ten major platforms to take reasonable steps to keep users under 16 off their services, with fines of up to A$99 million for serious or repeated failures. The law came into force on 10 December 2025 and had the support of parents, though tech firms opposed it.

Since the ban began, more than five million accounts understood to belong to people under 16 have been suspended or deactivated across the ten platforms, according to BBC reporting. Meta, which owns three of the platforms, said it closed about half a million accounts in the first few days. No company has been fined so far.

The government has since doubled the maximum fine for non-compliance to A$99 million, given the eSafety Commissioner greater discovery powers, and said it is preparing an enforcement lawsuit against some of the biggest platforms.

Reddit's case in court

Reddit and a libertarian advocacy group, the Digital Freedom Project, have gone to the High Court to contest the law in the first legal challenge to it. The hearing in Canberra began on Tuesday, 3 November, before a seven-judge panel. The plaintiffs said the law should be declared invalid because it violates an implied freedom of political expression in the country's constitution.

Reddit's barrister, Perry Herzfeld, told the court that barring under-16s from holding social media accounts stopped them from creating or responding to content on what he called the most important means of communication in the modern world. "That is a very profound restriction on political debate in Australia," he said.

Herzfeld called the legislation "ill thought out" and "inept", arguing that it did not call for any specific measure to keep out minors and failed to restrict other online services where cyberbullying took place, such as gaming websites. Reddit also argued the law should not apply to it anyway because it does not have some features central to social media, including a reliance on friend networks.

The government's defence

The Australian government and its Communications Minister, Anika Wells, a named defendant, have said they will defend the law. The government's barrister, Joanna Davidson, told the court that children were more vulnerable than adults to social media's addictive features because their brains were not fully developed.

Davidson argued that design features covered by the new platform rules — including autoplay video, recommendation systems, notifications switched on by default and the promotion of popular content — are broadly shared across all ten banned services, including Reddit, and become more harmful in combination, encouraging repeated visits driven by a fear of missing out.

Justice Jacqueline Gleeson questioned during the hearing whether most teenagers actually use social media for political discussion, noting that most young people spend most of their time online doing other things. The government began its response on Tuesday and continued on Wednesday, and the court will now hear the remainder of the government's case before deciding whether the ban stands or is narrowed. No verdict has been delivered.

Editorial disclosure

This article was researched with AI assistance and reviewed by the publisher before publication. Report factual errors through our contact page.

Frequently asked questions

What does Australia's social media ban cover?

It bans large social media platforms from letting under-16s hold an account. Ten major platforms must take reasonable steps to keep under-16s off their services, with fines of up to A$99 million for serious or repeated failures.

What is Reddit arguing in the High Court?

Reddit argues the ban is "ill-thought-out" and "inept", breaches an implied freedom of political communication in the constitution, and should not apply to Reddit because it lacks some features central to social media, such as friend networks.

Has the court decided the challenge?

No. The hearing began on 3 November 2026 before a seven-judge panel in Canberra, and the court was still hearing the government's case. No verdict has been delivered.

Sources & further reading

Sources reviewed 2026-11-07. Official statements describe the issuing organisation’s position; this article is an independent explainer.

Suggest a correction · More in Auto & Tech

Keep exploring